Posadism
Democratic Socialism & Left Populism

How Posadism actually answers

Most writing about Posadism describes what its thinkers argued. This page describes something different: what 73 people who landed on Posadism in our quiz said, question by question, compared with everyone else who took it.

Illustrated portrait of J. Posadas
J. Posadas

Reading these results

These are people the quiz placed in Posadism on the strength of these same answers, so the strongest agreements are partly built in.

The interesting figures are the ones further down: what this group is split on, and where it departs from the rest of the sample in ways the label alone would not predict. The comparison group is everyone who has taken the long quiz, which leans left of the general public.

Where they break from everyone else

The statements where this group is furthest from the rest of the sample.

PosadismEveryone who took the quiz
Fully disagreeNeutralFully agree
  • Markets naturally organize themselves better than governments can design them.

    Spontaneous Order · Economic axis · 72 answered

    This group sits 87 points further towards disagreeing than the average quiz taker.

  • Economic progress depends mainly on entrepreneurs taking risks, not on government planning.

    Entrepreneurship · Economic axis · 73 answered

    This group sits 85 points further towards disagreeing than the average quiz taker.

  • The traditional family of one man and one woman raising children is the best foundation for society.

    Family Structure · Social axis · 50 answered

    This group sits 79 points further towards disagreeing than the average quiz taker.

  • Incremental victories eventually produce systemic transformation.

    reform · Reform vs Revolution axis · 72 answered

    This group sits 73 points further towards disagreeing than the average quiz taker.

  • Electoral victories can accomplish complete socialist transformation.

    elections · Reform vs Revolution axis · 73 answered

    This group sits 73 points further towards disagreeing than the average quiz taker.

  • Men and women naturally have different roles in society that should be respected.

    Gender Roles · Social axis · 72 answered

    This group sits 66 points further towards disagreeing than the average quiz taker.

  • The economy would be fairer if more companies were owned by their workers instead of outside shareholders.

    Worker Ownership · Economic axis · 72 answered

    This group sits 66 points further towards agreeing than the average quiz taker.

  • The worth of a product comes only from what people are willing to pay, not from its labor or social benefit.

    Subjective Value · Economic axis · 73 answered

    This group sits 66 points further towards disagreeing than the average quiz taker.

What they nearly all agree on

The statements that divide this group least.

PosadismEveryone who took the quiz
Fully disagreeNeutralFully agree
  • Economic power always turns into political power, so inequality threatens democracy.

    Wealth & Power · Economic axis · 73 answered

    100% of them agreed.

  • The economy would be fairer if more companies were owned by their workers instead of outside shareholders.

    Worker Ownership · Economic axis · 72 answered

    100% of them agreed.

  • Economic progress depends mainly on entrepreneurs taking risks, not on government planning.

    Entrepreneurship · Economic axis · 73 answered

    100% of them disagreed.

  • Housing should be treated as a basic right, not mainly as an investment.

    Housing & Property · Economic axis · 73 answered

    100% of them agreed.

  • State enterprises serve public interests better than private firms.

    state · Ownership Model axis · 73 answered

    100% of them agreed.

  • Markets naturally organize themselves better than governments can design them.

    Spontaneous Order · Economic axis · 72 answered

    98% of them disagreed.

  • Democratic planning must replace market allocation mechanisms entirely.

    abolish · Market Usage axis · 73 answered

    98% of them agreed.

  • Parliamentary politics cannot defeat entrenched capitalist power.

    revolution · Reform vs Revolution axis · 72 answered

    98% of them agreed.

What they argue about

Sharing a label does not mean sharing an answer. These are the statements that split Posadism closest to evenly.

PosadismEveryone who took the quiz
Fully disagreeNeutralFully agree
  • Domestic consolidation must precede international commitments.

    domestic · International Strategy axis · 71 answered

    47% agreed, 45% disagreed.

  • The government should be able to monitor private communications if it improves national security.

    Surveillance · Governance axis · 73 answered

    45% agreed, 49% disagreed.

  • People should have the right to own weapons without heavy government regulation.

    Right to Bear Arms · Governance axis · 73 answered

    45% agreed, 50% disagreed.

  • Syndicalist organization avoids corruption inherent in politics.

    syndicalism · Party vs Union axis · 68 answered

    44% agreed, 50% disagreed.

  • It is better to let some guilty people go free than to risk punishing an innocent person.

    Due Process · Governance axis · 71 answered

    40% agreed, 50% disagreed.

  • Regulated markets distribute consumer goods with greater efficiency.

    regulate · Market Usage axis · 70 answered

    54% agreed, 42% disagreed.

  • It’s better for governments to balance budgets than to borrow heavily for new programs.

    Government Debt · Economic axis · 70 answered

    32% agreed, 55% disagreed.

  • All citizens should be required to complete military or civil service for the good of the nation.

    Mandatory Service · Governance axis · 73 answered

    34% agreed, 58% disagreed.

Their average position

Economic
Left74.1%

Averaged across 73 responses.

Governance
Libertarian2.3%

Averaged across 73 responses.

Social
Progressive59.8%

Averaged across 73 responses.

More on Posadism

Take the 60-question quiz